ADVANTAGES

In previous cross-sectional analyses, investigators have observed associations between mortality rates and particulate-air pollution, but the size of these associations was sensitive to efforts to control the analyses for potential confounders. Our analysis showed similar sensitivity for the strictly cross-sectional associations with life expectancy. The primary strength of this analysis, however, is the additional use of temporal variations. The availability of data on changes in pollution exposure across metropolitan areas from 1980 to 2000 provides the opportunity for an assessment that is similar to a natural experiment. Cross-sectional characteristics that do not change over time are controlled as if by design. Characteristics that affect life expectancy and that change over time — but not in correlation with changes in pollution — are unlikely to confound the results. Even with underlying spatial correlations, if the temporal changes in these characteristics are relatively less correlated, adjusted effect estimates from temporal regression models are likely to be more robust. In this analysis of differences in temporal changes, the estimated effects of reduced PM2.5 exposure on increases in life expectancy were robust in analyses adjusted for socioeconomic, demographic, and proxy variables for the prevalence of smoking, as well as in an analysis restricted to large counties.

Testimonials

Satisfied customers are saying